heard. Not only because it is their human right
to be heard. Not only because they have good
insights and ideas. Not only because we want to
live in a fair and egalitarian society. But because if
this generation feels silenced, there are real risks
to the country’s social fabric.33
For Māori, the experience of alienation from
housing and housing security is intergenerational
and systemic, stemming from colonisation.
Mainstream systems continue to fail Māori,
particularly taitamariki Māori, who have even less
chance of achieving meaningful housing security
or home ownership. The Māori dream of housing
security may not involve standard European
economic models, but requires agency and control
of land and resources, whānau and hapū-led
initiatives to develop papakāinga and whenua, and
assertion of rangatiratanga over mana whenua.34
If Māori are to be heard, and Māori experiences
and perspectives given space and weight, then
Te Ao Māori concepts of housing must be equally
understood and valued, both at the constitutional
partnership level and in local public participation
and democratic engagement.
Communities are calling for more public
participation and democratic engagement in the
housing system. Te Matapihi He Tirohanga Mō
Te Iwi Trust, the peak body for Māori housing
organisations, submitted in its recent claim to the
Waitangi Tribunal:35
The view of Te Matapihi having engaged in the
evidence from claimants and the Crown is that
there does need to be improvements to how
the Crown engage with Māori, seek their views
and take on board their input. Te Matapihi are
already a part of that, but their involvement and
input is not sufficient to be Treaty compliant,
the tino rangatiratanga whānau, hapū and iwi
Many disadvantaged communities are not heard
despite being most affected by, and concerned
about, the housing crisis. As the UN Special
Rapporteur on the right to adequate housing
noted in her recent report on New Zealand,
particular groups are experiencing the crisis most
acutely, including Māori, Pacific Peoples and
other ethnic communities, disabled people, youth
and children, single parents, and those living in
poverty.36 Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB) has 2,600
trained volunteers in more than 80 locations
around Aotearoa: they have their finger on the
public pulse. In their recent submission to HUD,
CAB explicitly recognises quality housing as a basic
human right and emphasises:
We need to ensure that those who are
most impacted by the housing crisis
(being those who are at most risk of not
having access to a home that is affordable,
healthy, accessible, secure) have a strong
voice in shaping our housing and urban
development system into the future. We
would like to see this reflected in the
formal structures that guide housing and
urban development policies, planning, and
implementation.37
There is considerable published evidence that
community participation in the health system
results in beneficial health and social outcomes.38
It is logical to infer that community participation in
the housing system results in beneficial housing
and social outcomes.
The Office of the Auditor-General’s recent report
on public accountability systems discusses the
role of the public sector in building trust and
confidence.39 Increasing gaps between the public
and the public sector can create an environment
where people feel disempowered and unheard.40
entitles them to engage in a partnership with
the Crown and that requires the Crown to seek
and take on board all those views provided.
21