incarceration, resulting in their families experiencing multiple hardships, about which many
prisoners expressed anguish. Often, the prisoner lamented that while he/she was being
offered three meals in prison, there was no one to provide even one meal to their family.
The Commission also found that numerous shortcomings in the functioning of the criminal
justice process contributed to extended incarceration of persons, particularly pre-trial
detention, which in turn, contributed to the creation of adverse living conditions and
treatment in prison. The manner in which bail is awarded, the administrative inefficiencies
of state institutions, such as the Attorney General’s Department, the lack of legal aid and the
poor utilization of alternatives to incarceration all contribute to more prisoners spending
longer periods of time in prison. Not only is this a huge burden on the taxpayer, but it also
results in diminishing returns because prisoners do not leave prison being prepared to
reintegrate into society and live as productive citizens. Instead, the system, as it currently
exists, could potentially result in released prisoners resorting to further criminality after
release in order to survive.
The correctional system therefore requires extensive reform if it is to fulfil its objective of
rehabilitating prisoners and ultimately preventing crime. It is hoped that this study will be
the foundation for formulating correctional policies that seek to provide effective
rehabilitation programmes that enable persons to live with dignity during and after their
term of imprisonment, rather than exacerbating the socio-economic and psychological
conditions that lead to criminality in the first place.
It must be highlighted that throughout this study, the Commission observed DOP officers to
be extremely aware of and empathetic towards the hardships faced by inmates within
prison, even in their personal lives. Prison staff were found willing to discuss the
shortcomings and weaknesses of the Department of Prisons, and officers themselves
provided insightful and progressive suggestions to improve the existing penal system and
transform it into a correctional system. Their recommendations were wide ranging,
encompassing the living conditions of prisoners, rehabilitation programmes to reduce the
rate of recidivism and even means of strengthening the criminal justice process. For this
reason, the Commission believes that prison officers at all ranks should be consulted in any
prison reform initiatives undertaken by the government.
Part I – Treatment and Conditions of Prisoners
1. Entrance and Exit Procedure
The process of admitting and registering a new inmate to prison was observed to be uniform
and consistent across all prisons but contained a number of shortcomings. For instance, the
information management system in prisons is highly inefficient as manual files, rather than
a digital centralized database, are used to store prisoners’ records, leading to delays in the
search and retrieval of files. Although a few prisons were observed to be operating an
electronic system of data management, the lack of IT proficient officers amongst the staff
limited the long-term success of these initiatives.
iv