Applying the HRBA Public Finance Framework to
Public Revenues
Applying the HRBA framework to public revenues acknowledges:
o
Why should one pay tax?
o Has the Philippines
mobilized
the maximum available financial
resources to
progressively realize human rights?
o
What kinds of taxes support the realization of human rights without discrimination?
A country mobilizes funds to deliver goods, services and facilities and create an environment
conducive for the realization of human rights. A country's finances are generally mobilized
through taxation, profits of public enterprises, fees collected from public services, public
offerings of government bonds (e.g., treasury bills and treasury bonds including retail treasury
bonds), foreign aid, expansion of the money supply (e.9., printing money), and public
borrowing. Deficit financing and public borrowing will be discussed in the next section; this
section will focus on taxation revenues, rather than non-taxation revenues, since taxation
revenues account for the bulk of the country's public revenues.t
Paying taxes
Paying taxes is a basic duty of all individuals and is consistent with Article 29 of the Universal
Declaration of Human Rights.e The United Nations Human Rights Committee has said that the
duty to pay tax is absolute and does not depend on the political or moral orientation of the
taxpayer. (Greggi, 2009)
"Paying tax is a critical part of state-building and strengthening democracy." (Christensen)
Taxes are used to provide public goods and services such as schools, health centers, roads
and emergency services that individuals alone cannot afford. Taxes also redistribute wealth
throughout society when these are used to provide social welfare and social protection goods,
services and facilities.
But government's tax power is limited by the boundaries of human rights; this means taxation
must have legitimate objectives, must be imposed by law that is accessible and understandable
by all, and must fully respect and guarantee human rights. Underpinning the tax system are the
following human rights principles:
o
The principle of proportionality, which links taxation to a person's ability to pay, or in
other words, the tax levied upon a taxpayer is based on her/his actual economic
capability;
8
ln 201 1, 88 percent of the country's revenues were programmed to be sourced from taxes; this percentage
increased to 91 percent in 2012; in 2013, it is projected that 93 percent of the country's revenues will come from
taxes; seeTable C.'l , "Revenue Program, By Source, 2011-2013," Department of Budget and Management, Budget
of Expenditures and Sources of Financinq, FY 2013.
sAlltda 29 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights states: "Everyone has duties to the community in which
alone the free and full development of his personality is possible."
5B