5
A human rights-based approach to native title reform
Text Box 5.1: PANEL PRINCIPLES: A human rights‑based approach11
Participation: everyone has the right to participate in decisions which affect
their human rights. Participation must be active, free and meaningful, and give
attention to issues of accessibility, including access to information in a form
and a language which can be understood.
Accountability: accountability requires effective monitoring of compliance with
human rights standards and achievement of human rights goals, as well as
effective remedies for human rights breaches. For accountability to be effective,
there must be appropriate laws, policies, institutions, administrative procedures
and mechanisms of redress in order to secure human rights. This also requires
the development and use of appropriate human rights indicators.
Non‑discrimination and equality: a human rights‑based approach means that all
forms of discrimination in the realisation of rights must be prohibited, prevented
and eliminated. It also means that priority should be given to people in the most
marginalised or vulnerable situations who face the biggest barriers to realising
their rights.
Empowerment: everyone is entitled to claim and exercise their rights and
freedoms. Individuals and communities need to be able to understand their
rights, and to participate fully in the development of policy and practices which
affect their lives.
Legality: a human rights‑based approach requires that the law recognises
human rights and freedoms as legally enforceable entitlements, and the law
itself is consistent with human rights principles.
As the Social Justice and Native Title Report 2015 noted: ‘To be consistent with these [human
rights] principles, laws and policies should be non-discriminatory and promote the ability of
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples to exercise choice, participation and control.’12
The complicating factor in seeing the extensive and multi‑faceted discrimination in the native
title system is that native title can only be claimed by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
peoples. Negative impacts of the system are felt only by us. The only people who are deprived
of control over our ‘assets’ and our culture through the native title system are First Nations
individuals and peoples.
This perhaps makes it hard for ‘outsiders’, such as policy and law makers, to see how
significantly the native title system undermines our enjoyment of the human rights which other
Australians take for granted and the barriers that it has created for us, despite the stated intent
to benefit us.13
Australian Human Rights Commission
19