14
Chasing the Wind: Assessing Philippine Democracy, Second Edition
closed system, democracy provides the greater challenge, the wider
opportunities; but not of repose, since 'repose' is not the destiny of man.
(Mayo, 1960:309)"
The professional literature on democracy and democratization has grown
much faster than on other social science concerns – Schmitter's own description
of this phenomenon is "a burgeoning of democratization studies" (2010: 18).
This proliferation of books, journal articles and even quasi-academic opinion
pieces on democracy and democratization obviously has to do with its nearly
universal appeal. Political regimes across the board, from left to right in terms of
ideological location and including some that are demonstrably antidemocratic, insist on at least a formal identication with this iconic regime. The
Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen, an economist, has actually repeatedly drawn
attention to this remarkable catholicity of democracy in current times. Other
writers have at various times commented similarly. (Amartya Sen, "Democracy
as a Universal Value" in Diamond and Plattner, 2009: xxviii, 315-320; Heywood,
2007: 71-72; also see Crick, 2002:8 and Mayo, 1960: 21-22)
Although most pronounced in the latter half of the 20th century (Lijphart,
1984:37; Huntington, 1993:3-5), democracy's popularity is not really a recent
phenomenon. In 1951, the UNESCO convoked over a hundred scholars
worldwide to study democracy and not one of those assembled registered a
negative attitude regarding the object of their collective study. The 1951
UNESCO report on the conference noted:
Probably for the rst time in history, democracy is claimed as the proper
ideal description of all systems of political and social organization
advocated by inuential proponents. (Democracy in a World of Tension,
UNESCO, Paris, 1951 as cited in Mayo, 1960:21.)
With the resurgence of ofcial policies explicitly promoting democracy
abroad in the early 1980s, democracy gained further popularity. The United
States, together with Britain, Germany, Holland and various international and
intergovernmental agencies including those of the United Nations, the World
Bank as well as many private foundations engaged in democracy promotion
worldwide and provided even more impetus for democracy studies. (Munck,
2009:2-12)
A decade later, Fukuyama's inuential End of History and the Last Man (1991)
would ride the same democracy bandwagon in implying that the nal political
arrangement – basically a well-developed liberal democratic state – might have
already come to stay. (Interestingly, much earlier, Hegel had also situated an
ultimate arrangement in the Prussian state of the 1830s (Berlin, 2003), a polity
that would be hard for people nowadays to recognize or accept as a modern
democracy.)
Midway Between Maximalist and Minimalist Conceptions of Democracy
This set of constituent ideas comprising democracy (popular sovereignty