Annual Report 2009-2010
4.376 Pursuant to the Commission’s directions, the District Magistrate, Gautam Budh Nagar,
U�ar Pradesh submi�ed a report along with a statement containing details of the amount
of monetary relief paid to the next of kin of the six deceased; five persons who sustained
bullet injuries; 41 others who sustained serious injuries and 231 persons who sustained simple
injuries. In addition, the details of the amount paid to the two persons who had lost their eye
sight and sustained head injury, was also furnished.
4.377 The Commission considered the report and called for comments of the complainant.
However, no comments were received.
4.378 The Commission observed that the petitioner has nothing to say on the report and closed
the case.
12. Killing of Yogesh in Fake Encounter in Indore, Madhya Pradesh
(CaseNo.1247/12/2002-2003 )
4.379 The Commission observed that the reports in the ma�er revealed that the victim had
fallen a�er being hit by one bullet and yet two bullets were fired at him. It thus recommended
payment of Rs. 3,00,000/- as monetary relief to the next of kin of the deceased victim.
4.380 The Commission’s recommendations have been complied with and the proof of payment
has alos been received. The Commission has closed the case.
13. Custodial Death of Javed Ahmed Magrey by Army Personnel in Jammu & Kashmir
(Case No. 22/9/2003-2004-AD)
4.381 The Commission observed that the allegations were substantiated in the magisterial
enquiry report and later on by police investigation. The Commission recommended to the
Ministry of Defence to pay a sum of Rs. 3,00,000/- as monetary relief to the next of kin of the
deceased victim.
4.382 The Ministry of Defence requested the Commission for extension of time till 31 May
2006 for payment of monetary relief. The Commission granted the required extension of time
and called upon the Ministry of Defence to submit proof of payment. The compliance report is
awaited.
14. Suicide by a 3rd Year Dalit Student due to Torture by Head of Pathology Department, Medical
College, Jhansi (Case No. 20640/24/2003-2004)
4.383 The Commission had recommended to the Government of U�ar Pradesh to pay a
compensation of Rs. 2 lakh (one lakh under violation of human rights and one lakh under the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act) to the next of kin of the
deceased. Since the compliance report to the recommendations made by the Commission had
not been received, it issued conditional summons to Principal Secretary, Medical Education,
U�ar Pradesh for appearance before it. In response, a report from the Principal Secretary, U�ar
Pradesh has been received but the proof of payment is awaited.
NHRC
77