People of Pacific cultural gendered identities
also played significant supporting roles in village,
community, church and educational life. Quite often,
the punake or musicians, choir conductors or poets
would be fa’afafine or leiti, while others would be
responsible for garland weaving, cooking and tapa
making.
The influence of missionaries and their teachings
since the 1800s has shifted Pacific worldviews of
gender away from fluidity and pansexuality towards
condemnation. In Aotearoa New Zealand, as social
acceptance and celebration of both gender identities
and sexual orientations increased in the mainstream,
Pacific communities, especially those involved in
churches, condemned the social attitudes, and the
people being accepted and celebrated.68 At the same
time, the voices of Pacific people who identified
with the unique genders of Pacific cultures69 were
silenced due to misrepresentation70 as well as
suppression by community and church leaders.
Religious belief is a powerful influence that can be
weaponised to discriminate. Some interpretations
of the Christian religion can further marginalise
minorities within the community. Pacific gender
and sexuality diverse peoples are one example
of this. Compared to heterosexual people, these
communities generally experience higher rates
of bullying, victimisation, suicide, verbal assault,
depression, tobacco smoking, alcohol use and
other drug dependence, all of which are barriers
to career advancement and can lead to workplace
discrimination.71 This discrimination is often
perpetrated and reinforced by family members
and church communities. There is a culturallyingrained paradigm that being sexually diverse or
being physically or mentally disabled is a curse,
68
69
70
71
72
73
22
or the consequence of wrongdoings by parents,
grandparents or ancestors. There is a growing
number of Pacific peoples now challenging these
prejudicial interpretations of religion and culture.
In its most recent recommendations, the Committee
for the Rights of the Child recommended that the
New Zealand government take affirmative action in
support of gay, lesbian, bisexual transgender and
intersex children, including Pacific children.72
Older Pacific people
Older people in Pacific families and communities are
known as elders, or matua. These terms recognise
the contributions of their wisdom and knowledge to
the family and community, as well as the care they
offer small children. Often, the welfare of elders and
matua is a matter for the extended family, and care
takes place within that context.
According to the 2018 Census, 10.6 percent of
the Pacific population, or 40,454 people, are aged
over 65. Due to historically low numbers of Pacific
elders, and the focus of the family environment,
little is known about Pacific peoples’ experiences of
retirement income and transitioning from work.
In 2018, the Health Research Council awarded a
research fund to a project which will investigate the
health and wellbeing of Pacific matua. It will seek to
understand the impacts of migration, housing issues,
work and living arrangements on matua wellbeing
and family care.
Katavake-McGrath (2020) – Unpublished PhD thesis, Pacific gay mens lived experience of legislative change.
Including Tongan leiti, Fijian vakasalewalewa, Tahiti and Hawai’ian mahu, PNG palopa, Samoan fa’afafine, Cook Islands
akava’ine, and Niuean fakafefine.
Brown-Acton (2011) Presentation at the 2nd Asia Pacific Outgames.
Human Rights Commission (2020) PRISM – Human Rights issues relating to Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity and
Expression and Sex Characteristics in Aotearoa New Zealand (https://www.hrc.co.nz/files/9215/9253/7296/HRC_PRISM_
SOGIESC_Report_June_2020_FINAL.pdf); Young people Attracted to the Same Sex or Both Sexes: Findings from the
Youth ’12 national youth health and wellbeing survey - https://www.fmhs.auckland.ac.nz/assets/fmhs/faculty/ahrg/docs/
Youth’12%20Young%20People%20Attracted%20to%20the%20Same%20or%20Both%20Sexes%20Report.pdf.
Committee on the Rights of the Child Concluding observations on the fifth periodic report of New Zealand 2016 CRC/C/
NZL/CO/5.
United Nations. 1966. International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. New York: United Nations.
Accessed at https://www.ohchr.org/en/professionalinterest/pages/cescr.aspx.
Talanoa: Human rights issues for Pacific peoples in Aotearoa New Zealand