NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION, INDIA
was undergoing sentence at the Central Jail, Agra. On 4.6.2013, at 1:30 P.M., while his son
was sleeping, one life convict Amarjeet (Joga), came to his barrack and attacked him with
stones. Consequently, Sonu suffered grievous injuries. The Superintendent of the Jail, had
lodged a report at Police Station Jagdishpura, Agra against Amarjeet which was registered
as FIR No. 304/2013 under Section 323/325 IPC. Sonu was shifted to MS Medical College,
Agra from where he was shifted to Gandhi Memorial Hospital, Lucknow. The complainant
was apprehensive about the life of his son.
ii.
The Commission called for an action taken report in the matter from the authority
concerned. Pursuant to the directions of the Commission, Additional Inspector General
(Administration), Prison Administration and Correctional Services, Uttar Pradesh. Lucknow
on 17.1.2014 had informed the Commission that the matter was enquired into by the
Deputy Inspector General, Prison Agra. In his Enquiry Report, it is concluded that Amarjeet
(Joga) had taken some money from the convict prisoner Sonu, son of Saveer, as a loan but
the same was not returned. On 4.6.2013 they had a hot discussion and Amarjeet (Joga)
had inflicted injuries to convict prisoner Sonu with stone. Consequently Sonu sustained
head injury and injury over the face and he was shifted to prison hospital. The same day
he was shifted to District Hospital, Agra, from where he was again shifted to Medical
College, Agra. On the recommendation of the doctors, Sonu was shifted to Medical
College, Lucknow. The doctor found a fracture over the face of Sonu. He had undergone
an operation in Medical College, Lucknow and was sent back to Central Jail, Agra. Enquiry
officer recorded the statement of Sonu who had informed him that proper treatment had
been given to him by the administration. His release order had also been received in the
jail on 26.12.2013.
iii.
On perusal of the material available on records, the Commission observed that it was
clear that the Senior Superintendent of Jail, in his report dated 7.9.2013 had concluded
that Head Warder Cheda Lal and Warder Abhey Ram had been found guilty of dereliction
of duty and they had been departmentally punished. It was also clear that convict prisoner
Sonu had sustained grievous injuries while in the custody of the Central Jail Agra. This
indicates that the Jail administration had failed to protect the body of Sonu which is a
clear case of violation of his human rights. Thus, victim Sonu was entitled for monetary
relief.
iv.
Accordingly, the Commission directed the Chief Secretary, Government of Uttar Pradesh
to show cause as to why the victim Sonu should not be recommended monetary
compensation of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand) from the State Government of Uttar
Pradesh as per provisions of Section 18(a)(1) of Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993. The
said direction was complied with by the State Government.
19. The complainant and his two associates, who were remanded to judicial custody at District
Prison, Mirzapur, UP, slapped, abused by caste names and threatened by the Jail warden.
ANNUAL REPORT 2019-20
71