HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION | A FAIR GO FOR A L L ?
importance of focusing on policies, and practices within
systems, not just on individual attitudinal changes:
The history of racism in medicine and healthcare ...
illustrates that the problem of healthcare disparities is not
simply one of individual behaviour. It is a problem that is
rooted in organisational and institutional structures and
• in 2010, there were 60 active Mäori psychologists
representing 4 percent of all active psychologists (1346).
Forty two (or 70 per cent of) active Mäori psychologists
were female. The main employers of active Mäori
psychologists were DHBs (15) and self employed practices
(15).103
practices. Given how embedded racism is in institutions
In 2010, the Ministry of Health published research on
such as healthcare, a significant shift in the system’s
Shifting Mäori Health Needs to enable the health workforce
policies, practices and procedures is required to address
to more appropriately meet the health needs of the growing
institutional racism and create organisational and
Mäori population. The report found that, given the projected
institutional change to reduce healthcare disparities.99
increase in the Mäori population over the next 10-20 years,
Health workforce diversity
it would be necessary to recruit over 150 Mäori students
into medical education each year for the next 10 years.
Another manifestation of structural discrimination is the
In addition, Mäori secondary school students needed to
under-representation of Mäori and Pacific peoples in the
be encouraged to study science and then be supported to
health workforce. A study of New Zealand’s District Health
successfully do so (at personal and curriculum levels). Mäori
Boards (DHBs) shows that only three per cent of the nearly
students in tertiary medical education also needed personal,
60,000 people employed by DHBs are Pacific peoples. In
pedagogical and curriculum support. Curriculum changes
the Auckland region, Pacific peoples are under-represented
in medical education are also being endorsed by health
in this sector, seven per cent of the workforce, despite
workforce and system planners here and internationally.
making up around 12 per cent of the regional population.100
Workplaces need to support Mäori doctors to be Mäori and
Additionally, most Mäori and Pacific DHB employees are
to practice within Mäori models of health care delivery.
concentrated in administrative and nursing roles.101
Achieving these targets requires a cross-government
Ministry of Health monitoring also offers data on the Mäori
approach.104
health workforce. According to their research:
A 2011 study on Future Directions for a Mäori Dental Health
• In 2009, active Mäori medical practitioners represented 3
Workforce, for example, highlighted the need to expand the
per cent of the medical practitioner workforce (330 out
of 11,164).102 Between 2006 and 2009, the number of
active Mäori medical practitioners increased from 240 to
330, an increase of 90 or 38 per cent (all active medical
practitioners increased from 9547 to 11,164, an increase
of 1617 or 17 per cent)
• between 2006 and 2010, the proportion of active Mäori
dental health workforce to optimise the oral health needs
of Mäori 0-17 year-olds. The study recommended structural
changes to the workforce including: raising the proportions
of Mäori dental health practitioners via incentives in the
education system (e.g. changes to the secondary curriculum
and recruitment into university); introducing cultural
competency training for non-Mäori oral health professionals;
the purchasing of more Mäori oral health services; and the
midwives was between 6 and 8 percent of the total
provision of oral health services at times and in places that
active midwife workforce. During this time, the number
are most accessible for Mäori whänau.105
of active Mäori midwives increased by 45 or 29 per cent
(2006, 153; 2010, 198), while the number of all active
midwives increased from 2303 to 2639, an increase of
336 or 15 per cent
• in 2008, there were 156 active Mäori dentists
Better representation of Mäori and Pacific peoples in
the health workforce would have significant benefits.
Mäori patients have higher rates of visits and increased
engagement with Mäori healthcare providers and likewise
for Pacific patients and Pacific providers.106 A report
representing 5 percent of all active dentists (3419). Of the
commissioned by the Ministry of Health shows that where
active Mäori dentists, 113 (or 72 per cent) were female
patients and healthcare professionals are of the same
ethnicity, there are better health outcomes for patients.107
21