Australian Human Rights Commission
Submission to the UN Committee On The Elimination Of Racial Discrimination, 30 October 2017
overstayed their visas, 145 had been detained after having their visa
cancelled on non-character grounds, 44 had been detained after being
denied entry at an Australian airport and five were undocumented or
inadequately documented seaport arrivals (such as stowaways). 228
186.
The average length of detention in immigration detention facilities has
increased significantly in recent years. The average rose from 72 days in July
2013229 to almost 400 days by August 2014, and has remained at or above
that level ever since.230 As at 31 August 2017, the average length of detention
was 445 days. Over a third of people in detention (36%) had been detained for
at least a year, and around a fifth (22%) had been detained for more than two
years.231
187.
As at 31 August 2017, there were 369 people (including 43 children) residing
in the Regional Processing Centre in Nauru and 773 adult men residing in the
Regional Processing Centre in Manus Island, Papua New Guinea. In both
countries, a significant number of people are also residing in the community
after having been released from Regional Processing Centres.232
Legislative framework
188.
Under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Migration Act), immigration detention
remains mandatory for all unlawful non-citizens.233 Australian courts do not
have jurisdiction to remove a person from detention on the basis that their
detention is arbitrary, and there is no legislative time limit on detention.
189.
Positive developments relating to immigration detention in recent years
include: the release of almost all children from closed facilities into alternative
community arrangements;234 the closure of several detention facilities;235
increased use of community alternatives to detention; commitment to
ratification of OPCAT; and the release of a number of refugees who previously
had been detained indefinitely due to having received an adverse security
assessment.
190.
However, the Commission is concerned about an increase in long-term
detention, an increase in the number of people detained due to visa
cancellation, and a small number of refugees who continue to be indefinitely
detained due to adverse security assessments.
191.
The Commission has recommended that the Australian Government continue
to expand the use of alternatives to closed detention and, where immigration
detention is necessary, ensure that it is time limited, strictly necessary (such
as for the purpose of public health and security checks) and subject to
individualised decision-making and judicial oversight.
192.
There are no minimum standards for conditions of detention codified in
Australian law. Introducing these standards would help to ensure greater
consistency in conditions across the detention network, prevent breaches of
Australia’s international obligations and facilitate access to appropriate
remedies if breaches do occur. The Commission’s publication Human rights
standards for immigration detention, which sets out benchmarks for the
36