Monitors had further regular meetings throughout the project implementation period to
discuss and agree on work ethics and receive specialized training on court monitoring
techniques. A group was also created on social media among project staff, making it possible
for them to exchange information in real time and consult others on issues and difficulties
encountered in their work.
With the help of a statistician, an electronic software was created enabling court monitors
to enter data collected each day directly into a database. Dedicated software was developed
using electronic forms on a tablet, ensuring that the forms are entered correctly. A
comprehensive automated cleaning data rules were developed between questions at the
level of the form to ensure consistency of questions and answers.
While most data contained in the report is based on direct observation of cases by ISTIQLAL
monitors during the reporting period, some quantitative data was obtained directly from the
court system. Data was extracted through the “Al-Mizan” software accredited by the Higher
Judicial Council.
Monitoring methodology
Prior to starting the monitoring activities, the project team devised a number of indicators
relevant to the monitoring goals. The indicators were then shared and discussed with
relevant counterparts, including judiciary representatives, human rights organizations and
all ISTIQLAL members.
In order to collect data in a streamlined fashion, ISTIQLAL developed five questionnaires that
were used by court monitors to collect data and input it into the database.
Both quantitative and qualitative approaches were used to collect data.
Monitored courts
The Courts that were the object of monitoring are all First Instance Courts in the Gaza Strip
(Gaza City and Khan Yunis), all First Instance Courts in the West Bank (Hebron, Bethlehem,
Ramallah, Jericho, Nablus, Jenin, Tulkarm and Qalqilya), and the Serious Crimes Court
branches in the same West Bank governorates.
The team also monitored cases pending before the Corruption Crimes Court, the study
community was limited to the Corruption Crimes Court and a conducted a pilot monitoring of
the juvenile courts in Ramallah, Al Bireh, Bethlehem, Nablus and Gaza. These courts are not
included in the present report and will be the object of separate thematic reports.
Timeframe and number of hearings monitored
Monitoring of trials before the Serious Crimes Court took place between 1 April and 19 June
2019, when Presidential Decree no. 14 of 2019 repealed the Decree Law no. 9 of 2018 that
had created the Serious Crimes Court. The team monitored 1.348 hearings spanning over 83
court days
Monitoring of trials before First Instance Courts in the West Bank took place between 19
June 2019 and 15 February 2020. The team monitored 7.846 hearings spanning over 506
12