Resources, priorities and trade-offs
91. The human right to a decent home is subject
to resource availability. Even high-income
countries, such as Aotearoa, cannot avoid
difficult decisions about resource allocation.
Priorities have to be set and trade-offs have to
be made.
92. Prioritisation and trade-offs are common
features of every approach to policy making. The
human rights approach, grounded on Te Tiriti, is
distinctive because of the conditions it imposes
on the policy making process, such as:33
a) explicit acknowledgment of colonisation
and serious attention to its continuing
impacts;
b) honouring of Te Tiriti and the partnership
between kāwanatanga (Crown) and
rangatiratanga (hapū and iwi) e.g.
government to work in partnership and
share decision-making with its Tiriti
partners, and advance equitable outcomes
for Māori;
c) priority-setting inevitably requires value
judgements, so it is crucial to be explicit and
clear about which values are being relied
upon;
d) there must be a time-bound strategy or
plan of action, and housing is no exception;
e) equity, equality and non-discrimination
rule out any trade-offs which would result
in, or deepen, unequal and discriminatory
outcomes;
f) priority should be given to the poorest,
most vulnerable, and most disadvantaged
individuals and communities;
34
Human Rights Commission
g) priority-setting must involve the active and
informed participation of those affected (in
relation to tangata whenua, see (b) above);
h) no trade-offs are permitted in relation to
core obligations of immediate effect;
i) constructive accountability mechanisms are
needed to ensure trade-offs are fair and
equitable.
These conditions apply to policy making in relation
to the right to a decent home grounded on Te Tiriti.
Guideline 18: The right to a decent home
grounded on Te Tiriti places measurable
obligations on central and local government.
Full implementation of the right to a decent
home may be progressively realised over
time. But central and local government
must take deliberate, concrete and targeted
steps towards realisation of the right to a
decent home. Government has a specific and
continuing obligation to move as expeditiously
and effectively as possible towards the
human right’s full implementation. Progress
(or otherwise) must be tracked by suitable
indicators and benchmarks. When prioritising in
relation to the right to a decent home, certain
conditions apply, such as consideration of
colonisation and its continuing impacts, Te Tiriti
and the most disadvantaged individuals and
communities, including those living in poverty.