THE RIGHT TO HEALTH IN PRISON:
RESULTS OF A NATIONWIDE SURVEY AND REPORT
2.33 The Commission is of the view that these subsections place a statutory
responsibility on the Ministry of Health to ensure the appointment of
Medical and Dental Officers for prisons, as well as being responsible for
the delivery of health services in prisons.
2.34 To illustrate further, Section 37(1)35 of the Act states that in cases of serious
illness of a prisoner confined in a prison in which there are inadequate
facilities for the treatment of that prisoner, the Officer-in-Charge, or in
his absence, the next senior prison officer on duty may, on the certificate
of a Medical Officer, make an order for the removal of the prisoner to a
government hospital. This in the Commission’s view further emphasises
the role of Ministry of Health in the delivery of health care and medical
services to prison.
2.35 However, Section 1536 of the Prison Act 1995 stipulates that a Medical
Officer and a Dental Officer appointed under section 14 shall be under the
control and supervision of the Commissioner General whilst in prison, and
shall perform such duties as may be prescribed.
2.36 In this regard, the Commission advises that such a situation gives rise to a
direct conflict between the duties of a doctor / medical staff to his patient
(prisoner), and his statutory obligations towards the prison administration.
To illustrate further, if the prison doctor serves dual roles, functioning as
both medical specialist and at the same time is directly subordinated to
the Commissioner General rather than being part of the civil health care
structure, he will have a very difficult and sensitive role to fulfil.
2.37 The Commission advises that health care and medical staff in prison should
act exclusively as caregivers.
37. (1) In case of serious illness of a prisoner confined in a prison in which there are inadequate facilities for the treatment of
that prisoner, the Officer-in-Charge may, on the certificate of a Medical Officer, make an order for the removal of the prisoner
to a government hospital.
(2) Where, a prisoner removed under subsection (1) is, in the opinion of the medical officer of the hospital, still necessary
for the prisoner to remain in the hospital, the medical officer shall, at the end of each month, transmit a certificate stating that
fact to the Officer-in-Charge of the prison from where the prisoner was removed.
36
15. A Medical Officer and a Dental Officer appointed under section 14 shall be under the control and supervision of the
Director General whilst in prison and shall perform such duties as may be prescribed.
35
26